With changes to the incoming electric vehicle (EV) mandate going back and forth all the time – the latest from the EU is that it has cut the proposed reduction of fleet CO2 targets from 100 per cent to 87.5 per cent for 2035 – it can be hard to know which fuel or propulsion-type you should choose for your next vehicle.
So while it looked, only a few years ago, like everyone would have to move to EVs sooner rather later as manufacturers made announcements about killing off pure petrol and diesel products, now in the later 2020s it would seem internal-combustion cars still have some life in them yet.
And if you mix hybrids (HEVs) and plug-in hybrid (PHEVs) into the consideration, then the options become ever more confusing still. Here, we go over the four major fuel types for cars, and identify which one is best suited for all different groups of Irish drivers in 2027 and beyond.
Petrol
Looking like it was doomed recently, some carmakers have admitted that they’re going to continue developing petrol vehicles going deep into the 2030s, so it can still suit plenty of drivers in 2027 and make for a sound new- or used-car purchasing choice for the next few years – rising petrol prices notwithstanding.
Lumped in here are mild-hybrid electric vehicles (MHEVs) with petrol engines, because this very modest electrical augmentation only really works like an extended auto-start-stop system – so a petrol MHEV drives and operates almost identically to a purely petrol car.
If you don’t do an awful lot of kilometres annually, but you also don’t do a lot of your distance in congested towns and cities, then petrol could be your best choice. You can’t end up with a blocked diesel particulate filter, for example, and also there are still plentiful petrol/MHEV options on the scene right now.
Petrol is probably also the obvious choice for a performance car if you’re a driving enthusiast, although there’s a rising breed of high-power PHEVs and EVs which can challenge this assumption.
The main drawback of a petrol car is that you are likely to spend more on motor tax each year, due to a higher level of CO2 tailpipe emissions.
Pros: Good for low-km drivers, plenty of choice Cons: Can be pricey to run, increased taxes
Diesel
Once the darling of the buying public in the middle of the last decade, diesel is on the wane these days – not helped by the fact some manufacturers have walked away from the fuel type entirely and others are deleting it from ranges where you’d normally expect to find a diesel model.
But diesel still has a place for certain motorists. Like petrol engines, diesels can use mild-hybrid technology to help with economy and emissions, yet for long-range, high-speed drivers – i.e., people who do most of their driving on the country’s motorways – who are often up against time constraints (and so do not want to be waiting to recharge the vehicle for long periods during a given journey) then diesels are still ideal.
If you want something that can go 500, 800 and even over 1,000 kilometres at a time with ease, without stopping and thus in the least time possible, this remains the best option. But don’t buy it if you do lots of short journeys, in and around town as you’ll end up with clogged diesel particulate filter issues before you know it.
Pros: Ideal for long-distance cruising, high-speed efficiency Cons: Not great for short-range drivers, less choice these days
Hybrid
We’re putting both HEVs (non-plug-in) and PHEVs (plug-in) under one banner here. HEVs, despite having been around as a drivetrain type for longer than PHEVs, are less widespread these days, but Asian manufacturers – such as Toyota, Honda, Kia and Hyundai – are big fans of the propulsion method, while the Volkswagen Group is, surprisingly, in the process of introducing a new HEV powertrain to all its brands.
HEVs are great for people who want a greater degree of urban-based engine-off motoring, but who do not have the necessary plug-in-charging infrastructure either at their place of work or their residence. So if you don’t have a driveway or garage to have a wallbox, a HEV could be for you.
PHEVs are a little more intensive for owners to use, as to get the best possible economy from them, you need to plug them into the mains regularly and ensure you’re not using their internal-combustion engines too often. But if you can do that, either at home or work, then PHEVs are going to be absolutely ideal for certain people.
Specifically, if most of your week-in, week-out commuting is in urban and semi-urban environments, and you can plug the car in a lot, then you’ll get mega fuel efficiency from these PHEVs. And yet, if you do occasionally need to go long-distance, the engine portion of their drivetrain means you can do so more easily than in pure EVs.
But remember: plugging a plug-in hybrid into the mains regularly is the key to long-term ownership success. Clue’s in the name, folks.
HEV pros: more engine-off urban driving than MHEVs, fuss-free ownership HEV cons: less availability, will still burn fuel
PHEV pros: lengthy electric-only running available, capable of long-distance trips PHEV cons: Need to be plugging in often, normally expensive to buy
Electric
One day in the future, potentially all cars will be EVs – so many take the view we should get onboard with them now. And, in fairness, recent advances in battery tech, charging speeds and motor efficiency mean that a lot of EVs are much longer-range today than they were only four or five years ago.
EVs are optimum for urban and semi-urban commuters who don’t often need to travel the length of the country in one hit. While ‘range anxiety’ is a somewhat archaic term these days, there’s still the issue that many EVs are not at their most efficient when cruising steadily at 120km/h, which reduces their one-shot driving capability. Not to mention the lacklustre public charging network.
But the benefits of driving an EV cannot be ignored. With no combustion engine onboard whatsoever, they are typically much quieter and more comfortable than almost any other propulsion type. And they’re incredibly straightforward to drive, too: simply put them in D and off you go. You can even, on most versions, drive them using one pedal alone, if the regenerative braking level is strong enough.
The crucial note to end on here is that EVs still make by far the most financial sense to owners, if you can have a home wallbox. If you can only charge at expensive public DC points, you will find EVs are no more affordable to run on energy costs alone than a petrol or diesel car.
Pros: Smooth to drive, refined, ideal for urban streets, low taxes Cons: can still be compromised for long-range journeys, you absolutely need a home wallbox