What car will I replace my Galaxy with?

What car will I replace my Galaxy with?

Hi guys,

Firstly could I please ask what trade in value should I get for our 2008 Ford Galaxy 1.8 TDCi with 79,000 miles in excellent condition? We don't have service history as a mechanic relative serviced it (probably foolishly?). We hope to go for a new / nearly new car. One child but wife fills Galaxy with luggage regularly for trips to holiday home 225 miles away. Would like to get some MPV/SUV that has a highish driving position (both bad backs), but has a wheel well that we can put a full spare wheel and tyre into. Hate space savers / foam for our regular long journeys. Must lift in full spare and wedge behind drivers seat, which is a nuisance and worryingly potentially dangerous to our eight-year-old or ourselves if it became dislodged. Could stretch to €42,000 - 45,000 before decent trade in. What car would you recommend?

How would Audi Q5 be storage wise versus Galaxy and would full wheel go into wheel well?

Many thanks,

Mick

Our answer:

Hi Mick,

If you’re buying new or nearly-new then I’m afraid you’re going to struggle to find anything with a full-size spare wheel, especially if it’s an MPV or SUV that you’re looking for. Given the packaging requirements and the need to save weight for the official EU fuel consumption and CO2 tests, almost all car makers are ditching spares in favour of space savers or cans of squirt-and-inflate. That said, I think I’ve found the one that does still come with a proper, full-size spare as standard and it’s the Kia Carens. Thankfully, it’s also a really nice car – handsome and good to drive and offering cracking value. Will it be as spacious as the Galaxy? No, I’m afraid not, but it’s still pretty massive inside and should prove the right height and provide the right sort of seat comfort for your bad backs (as a fellow sufferer, I sympathise entirely…). It’ll also be vastly cheaper to run than the Galaxy. Mind you, one caveat – when it comes to spare tyres, always check with the dealer. Often a car that comes with a space saver or repair kit as standard can be optionally equipped with a full-size spare, so it’s always worth asking the question.

As for the Audi Q5, well it comes with a space saver as standard, but even then it’s never going to hold the kind of luggage that the Galaxy would. A lovely car though, so possibly worth compromising on the space/space saver issues for.
 
Your Galaxy should be worth in the region of €13-15,000 as a trade-in, but that lack of a proper service history will hurt it. Check with your mechanic relative to find out if any of the local dealerships know him and his work – that might help a bit, but either way, having no properly stamped service book is going to be a drag on the value. 
Shane O'Donoghue

Have a motoring question? Ask us here!

Ask us anything motoring related and please provide as much information as possible so we can give you the most accurate advice.

For more information please read our privacy policy.