116d, Golf or Focus - from 2012?

116d, Golf or Focus - from 2012?

Looking at buying a 2012 BMW 116d, 2012 Golf 1.6 tdi match or 2012 focus titanium. All cars have c. 35k miles. Which car would you recommend?

Our answer:

Hi Stephen,

The  BMW is the fun one – rear-drive, pokey motor and Bavarian attitude. Not the most practical thing in the world though and servicing can be pricey if you’re expecting hatchback running costs. The Focus is ultra-seenisble, not without a dash of style and very smooth and pleasant to drive, but space in the back isn’t great and the cabin looks and feels a bit dowdy. The Golf treads the middle ground – Germanically stylish, enjoyable to drive without being massively fun and there’s plenty of space in the cabin and boot. Overall, it’s still the best one. 

Shane O'Donoghue

Have a motoring question? Ask us here!

Ask us anything motoring related and please provide as much information as possible so we can give you the most accurate advice.

For more information please read our privacy policy.